I am happy there is someone who is willing to give me their honest opinion of my work. It can be difficult to a) find someone who is willing to read anything, let alone something I wrote and b) find someone who will not pull punches when it comes to problems with plot, story, characters, etc.
I gave one such friend a manuscript for a short-story/novella I am writing and the response I received went a bit like this:
Okay, in all seriousness, it was for the best. Sure, she wrote a diss track on my story, but none of her critiques stemmed from hatred or toxicity. She even told me she liked the story in spite of its many, many problems. Most of the issues she commented on I had seen for myself and agreed with.
I don’t get writers that won’t take any type of criticism. I’ve had many writing classes and in each there is at least that one person who insists they are the next J.K. Rowling and refuse to believe that anything negative said about their work is be true.
The teacher is just jealous or that editor didn’t “get” the story, etc.
This may be condescending of me, but I have a nagging suspicion most of these writers aren’t going anywhere.
How do you expect to get any better if you don’t even know if you’re doing something wrong? Would it be better if your sky diving instructor didn’t tell you how to properly jump out of a plane?
Having a beta reader is undeniably crucial in my opinion. It’s so much easier to see what elements require further explanation, or which characters need more development.
Everything I type comes from my own head so I have the benefit of all that background information. The reader does not.
That doesn’t mean I’m immune to saltiness when it comes to remarks made against my babies, but I have learned that most thought-out criticisms have merit.
In the end, it’s worth all of the blows to the ego in order for my story to become the best that it can be.
1 thought on “Letting My Friend Break My Kneecaps, or Getting Constructive Criticism”
Honestly, I used not take criticism well, but over time I learned to get better. Like you said, feedback is needed to make the story better. By not listening to people, I was working against improving my own story.
LikeLiked by 1 person