Perhaps I’m just whingeing over semantics here, but I had to get this off my chest.
When I purchased the audiobook for Neil Gaiman’s book on short stories I was very excited. Not only am I a fan of Gaiman’s writing, I am also a big fan of his narration. His dulcet tones and faint English accent make him a perfect narrator.
I was preparing myself for another boring day of organizing charts upstairs at the dermatology clinic where I worked and I needed something to listen to in order to keep the monotony from reducing my brain to yogurt.
So I placed the charts on a table, plugged in my earbuds, and I began to listen.
Gaiman gave a perfect introduction into this collection, explaining how he’d come to discover the term “trigger warning.” He conceded that, while trigger warnings may be well intentioned, sometimes we need to read things that make us uncomfortable, that force us to ponder imponderable things, see the world in darker hues.
He warned us readers (or listeners in this case) that what we were about to read would likely disturb us.
I listened for several hours, nearly finishing the book in it’s entirety during a single shift. It was interesting, imaginative, captivating, visceral, everything a book should be. However, there is one thing that it was not: triggering.
I loved the stories, loved the narration, but I kept listening with a growing sense of expectation. Is this the story that’s going to trigger me? Is this the story that’s going to challenge my preconceptions about life and put me on a 2001: A Space Odyssey styled journey to self-discovery?
The answer to that would be a nope.
Again, I loved the stories, in fact I consider this the best short-story collection I’ve ever read.
But with a title like Trigger Warning you expect something a little more…triggering. That’s not to say they weren’t disturbing. There are stories with murder, revenge, cannibalism, monsters, stalking, etc. They’re horrifying and dark with lovely twists and turns, but nothing I wasn’t expecting from something written by Gaiman.
And they were not what I was advertised.
Now, it’s not Gaiman’s responsibility to make sure that I, specifically, have all of my desires met. He is perfectly entitled to write what he wants and I believe he he does an excellent job of it.
However, let me explain why I was a bit disappointed.
There has, I think, been a shortage of books and stories in recent years that truly push the envelope. Books and stories that challenge ideas and behaviors that we see routinely in our day-to-day lives.
In our new easily-offended world there are any number of taboo subjects that deserve to be explored, but it would seem as if no one has the nerve to tackle them in a literary capacity in a long while, lest someone get their grandma panties in a wad.
I was hoping that Gaiman, in his uniquely stylized way, would touch upon such subjects or, at least, ignore the restraints that these perpetually offended people insist writers use. Nonetheless, there wasn’t much in his book that would truly “trigger” someone, provided that person doesn’t live in a perpetual state of duress.
I just wanted something a little more challenging. I wanted Gaiman to approach the likes of Lovecraft or King and throw down the gauntlet, saying, “No, gentlemen, this is scary.”
I’ve read a handful of the Sandman comics, I know what he’s capable of.
I only wish he’d gone balls-to-the-walls the way he did with that series.
Now that would have been truly triggering.
3 thoughts on “Why I’m Disappointed By Neil Gaiman’s “Trigger Warning””
You are not alone. I kept reading; I kept waiting to be triggered. Gaiman has taken me many places I have never anticipated — places others have told me they didn’t appreciate or understand, like the ocean at the end of the lane — but I was with him all the way, and I DID appreciate. I even felt glimpses of understanding. Neverwhere was a revelation. Coraline disturbed and repelled me. While Trigger Warning was worthwhile reading, the title and the warning broke the truth in advertising laws.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yeah. I can’t imagine anyone with any experience reading Gaiman would be triggered by this collection. Unless they were a member of the perpetually offended that I mentioned lol. Glad to know someone else felt the same way.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I felt the same thing after reading it. Not that I want to be “triggered” per se, but I expected to be shocked or maybe scared in a way I hadn’t before and that didn’t happen for me. It was gorgeous writing and I’d be so lucky to ever write anything as good, but I also had the same sense of confusion at the title.
LikeLiked by 1 person